Is It Bias or Are You Just Happy to See Steve Get Another Promotion?
Ah, bias. That sneaky, shapeshifting, well-dressed party crasher that somehow always ends up on the invite list, especially at work.
Whether it’s in hiring decisions, who gets praised for “taking initiative” ahem… Steve, or the subtle shift in tone when someone says “she’s ambitious” vs. “he’s driven.” Bias tends to show up wearing a nametag that says “Totally Objective Decision-Maker.”
But let’s break this down without making it sound like a legal deposition.
Bias Isn’t Just “That Guy from HR”
When we think about bias, it’s tempting to picture a cigar-smoking old-timer growling about how “things were better when men were men and women brought the coffee.” But let’s not oversimplify.
Bias is everywhere. It’s in our systems, our policies, our lunchroom jokes, and even in our job postings that say things like “rockstar,” “competitive,” and “willing to work 90 hours a week because sleep is for the weak.” You know. Totally neutral.
And it’s not just the big, glaring stuff. It's the soft, “well-meaning” stuff too. Like when someone calls you “too nice” to lead. Or when a woman is described as “helpful” while her male colleague is called “a visionary.”
The Numbers Don’t Lie But They Do Raise an Eyebrow
Let’s just hit a few highlights from a Catalyst study that basically confirmed what women have been shouting into the void for decades:
90% of millennial women say gender discrimination in the workplace is real. Only 57% of men agree. Apparently, 43% of men have excellent noise-cancelling headphones.
84% of women believe bias holds them back. Only 43% of men say the same. That’s not just a gap, it’s a canyon.
And here’s the kicker: 71% of men believe women just need to try as hard as they do to get ahead. If only trying hard came with a maternity leave plan, flexible hours, and someone else picking up the daycare drop-off.
Second-Generation Bias: The Cool-Sounding Name for a Not-So-Cool Problem
One of the trickiest forms of bias is second-generation bias. This is the kind that masquerades as “gender-neutral,” but was designed in a boardroom full of dudes named Chad back in 1982.
It’s the office culture that values being available 24/7 but forgets that not everyone has a spouse who handles everything else. It’s the “merit-based” promotions that somehow keep promoting the same type of person over and over again. Spoiler: It’s not a coincidence.
So What Do We Do?
We can start by:
Noticing it. Once you start tuning into gendered language “She’s so bossy” vs. “He’s got leadership potential”, you won’t be able to un-hear it. Sorry. Welcome to the club.
Calling it out. Nicely. Smartly. But firmly. Like: “Hey, maybe instead of saying she’s ‘emotional,’ we could say she’s passionate and invested in the outcome?”
Interrupting it. Whether you’re in a hiring meeting, writing a job post, or doing performance reviews ask yourself: Would I say this about a man?
Final Thoughts - AKA The Pep Talk You Didn’t Know You Needed
Bias is complex. It’s exhausting. And sometimes, it feels like trying to swim upstream in a suit made of bricks. But awareness is step one. And if you’ve read this far, you’ve already taken it!
Remember, changing systems takes time. But changing conversations? That starts today. Right now. In your next meeting. Your next email. Your next chance to say, “Actually, I think we should take another look at this.”
Let’s stop calling bias “just the way things are” and start calling it what it is: a fixable flaw in the system.
If you found this helpful, you’ll feel right at home in our newsletter. It’s where we share our best tools, ideas, and behind-the-scenes guidance for practice owners and health leaders. Sign up today!